Mill Configuration Comparison

High Strength Material Tube: Mill Configuration Comparison

Below are videos comparing the results of the two simulations. Both simulations are testing the same forming progression through the breakdown and fin passes of a high-strength material tube with a high thickness to diameter ratio, but utilizing two different mill configurations.

Mill #1 is a smaller mill and consists of smaller horizontal distances between the stands, and the rolls are smaller in diameter. Mill #2 is the larger of the two mills, has larger horizontal distances between the stands, and larger diameter rolls.

High-Strength Tube – Light Wall – Mill 1 – Center Portion

High-Strength Tube – Light Wall – Mill 2 – Center Portion

High-Strength Tube – Light Wall – Mill 1 – Full Length

High-Strength Tube – Light Wall – Mill 2 – Full Length

The results show the larger diameter rolls weren’t able to overcome the effect of the larger horizontal distances between the stands. These larger horizontal distances allow for more springback between stations, resulting in increased longitudinal strain along the strip edge, which leads to a greater tendency for buckling along the strip edge.


On-Time Delivery


First Time Performance

Still Searching For Answers?

Roll over to our Worlds Leading Resource Center

Search our Resources

No One Else Does What We Do

Roll form tooling tested at our facility or yours

Illustration of three linked gears small medium and large. Learn More

Detailed setup package & technician's testing remarks

Illustration of a piece of paper with lines on it to indicate writing. Learn More

Tooling drawing fully detailed

Illustration of a pencil. Learn More

Technicians available to troubleshoot at your facility

Illustration of a technician bust wearing a hat with with a wrench below the technician. Learn More

Tooling shipped in foam-filled wooden crates

Illustration of a box with all 4 top flaps open. Learn More

If it's not right, we'll make it right. Guaranteed.

Time to Roll Profits!

Have a technical question?

Need a quote from one of our performance specialists?

Simply contact us here or call and get answers 24/7.

Contact Us (888) 953-9400

Roll-Kraft Hosts Latest Live Tube and Pipe Training Seminar

Roll-Kraft’s latest tube and pipe mill training seminar was held on October 24, 2023 at the Waverly, Nebraska Venue location.

➤ Read More

Live Tube and Pipe Seminar - October 24th

Mill operators, maintenance supervisors, engineers, tool room personnel and management will all benefit from the program by learning new skills & produce a better quality product in less time.

➤ Read More

Roll-Kraft announces the Semi-retirement of Robert A. Sladky, Vice President of Tube Mill Engineering 

Robert's extensive expertise in the tubing industry spans over five decades, including 33 years of service at Roll-Kraft.

➤ Read More